Single center series: Malignancies transmitted by kidney transplant: probable cholangiocarcinoma (2016)

Status: 
Ready to upload
Record number: 
2311
Adverse Occurrence type: 
MPHO Type: 
Estimated frequency: 
This single center series reports three different malignancies which are donor transmitted or donor derived: Case 1: Meningioma: (Council of Europe, 2018): Extra-neural metastases by histologically benign meningiomas are very rare. Organs from potential donors with these types of tumours have a minimal risk of transmission. Anaplastic or malignant meningiomas (WHO grade III) are more aggressive meningeal tumours that occasionally can be associated with extra-neural metastases. Organs from potential donors with these tumours are considered low to intermediate risk if no risk factors are present. The transmission risk of anaplastic or malignant meningiomas is increased (high risk) in cases with previous interventions such as tumour resection, ­ventriculo-peritoneal/-atrial drainage and/or cranial chemo-/radiotherapy. Case 2: Urothelial Carcinoma Most recent risk assessment for urothelial carcinoma (Council of Europe, 2018): No literature exists regarding newly diagnosed urothelial cancer and organ donation. Therefore, the highest caution is recommended and the advice of a urologist may be sought in assessing the individual donor tumour transmission risk. National recommendations should be followed since they vary in accepting these tumours. In the case of patients with a history of urothelial carcinoma, it must be remembered that these tumors tend to be multicentric and can recur. Kidney transplantation is considered to be associated with an increased risk but the extent of this has not been classified. Similarly, potential donors with a past history of urothelial carcinoma and a disease free interval of at least 5 years should be assessed based on estimate of the probability of cure. No specific recommendations are available from the literature. Case 3: adenocarcinoma of unknown origin (suspected to be cholangiocarcinoma but unproven): no estimate possible.
Time to detection: 
Case 1: 13 months. Meningioma (malignant): Donor was intially diagnosed with Astrocytoma Grade II. 13 months after transplant a biopsy done in the setting of hydronephrosis showed malignant meningioma of donor origin and the diagnosis of astrocytoma in the donor was changed to malignant meningioma. Case 2: 11.75 years Urothelial Carcinoma: Case 3: 4 months
Alerting signals, symptoms, evidence of occurrence: 
Case 1: worsening kidney function + imaging performed because of hdronephrosis showed widespread metastatic tumor Case 2: hematuria Case 3: flank pain, anorexia, imaging at CT: infiltration of perinephritic fat, ureteral dilatation, abdominal lymph nodes enlarged, CA 19-9 elevated
Demonstration of imputability or root cause: 
Case 1: HLA-DR genotype of the tumor corresponded to donor HLA-DR genotype. The liver & heart recipients from the same donor did not develop malignancy. Case 2: Sex chromosome analysis showed a female (donor) genotype of tumor cells in this male recipient. Case 3: No studies performed; however, the recipient of the contralateral kidney died of metastatic tumor and the liver recipient also died of tumor. Heart and pancreas recipients were free of tumor.
Imputability grade: 
3 Definite/Certain/Proven
Groups audience: 
Suggest new keywords: 
Malignancy
Single Center Series
Kidney transplant
Kidney recipient
CNS tumor, other or type not specified
Urothelial (transitional) cell carcinoma
Cholangiocarcinoma
Therapy discussed
Donor derived
Meningioma
Suggest references: 
Georgieva LA, Gielis EM, Hellemans R, Van Craenenbroeck AH, Couttenye MM, Abramowicz D, Van Beeumen G, Siozopoulou V, Van Rosmalen M, Bracke B, Hartman V, De Greef K, Roeyen G, Chapelle T, Ysebaert D, Bosmans JL. Single-Center Case Series of Donor-Related Malignancies: Rare Cases With Tremendous Impact. Transplant Proc. 2016 Oct;48(8):2669-2677. doi: 10.1016/j.transproceed.2016.07.014. PMID: 27788799.
Note: 
Uploaded MN 5/8/22 first review CLFF 5/31/22 for IT: Please duplicate if decision is on 3 different files Second review MN: 1/27/23 Please clone this record: I think we need to add meningioma to the subcategory of CNS tumors, if it is not already there. The three records would be for meningioma, cholangiocarcinoma, and urothelial carcinoma under the malignancy types - OK (EP)
Expert comments for publication: 
This report documents two donor transmitted (patients 1 and 3) and one donor derived (patient 2) tumors. In all three cases, removal of the graft and cessation of immunosuppression led to tumor remission and prolonged survival (Patient 1 20 years, patient 2 3 years, patient 3 approximately 3 years). The report does document the ability of this approach to effect tumor remission, although the variables that would favor remission versus tumor progression remain undefined. The cases are well documented, and this paper is a good model to show how to properly report exampes of donor-related cancers in transplant recipients. It is also noteworthy that in the first case, transmission of tumor to several recipients led to revision of the original donor biopsy diagnosis of astrocytoma to malignant meningioma.